"Pop Internationalism"
Jim Blair

Pop Internationalism
by Paul Krugman
MIT Press, 1996
221 pages.

This book has 13 chapters, each a previously published essay or speech (except chapter 7 which is a review Krugman wrote of Laura Tyson's "Who's Bashing Whom?" for the New York Review of Books. They rejected it.)

The other chapters were first published in a wide range of places: Foreign Affairs, Harvard Business Review, American Economic Review, Peace Economics Peace Science and Public Policy, The Wilson Quarterly, New Perspectives Quarterly, Science, and Scientific American.

There is some redundancy and overlap between chapters because of this, but I found the book to be interesting and worthwhile. Krugman confirms many points about international trade (and economics in general) that I have made in many of my posts and web page items, so of course I enjoyed the book :-)

And I don't always agree with him: see my review of Peddling Prosperity (on my web page).

Chapter titles include "Does Third World Growth Hurt First World Prosperity?" ,"The Myth of Asia's Miracle" and "Technology's Revenge".

Is trade like war?

The main theme is that we hear too much about the supposed similarity of foreign trade with either war or sports or business. So much so that many people have come to believe this analogy. But, as he stresses, there are basic differences that render this comparison worse than useless.

While sports is a "win/lose" situation, and war can be "win/lose" or "lose/lose even more", trade is "win/win". The world is better off because of trade and so are most people. A corporation that does not keep up with the competition may go out of business, but countries do not.

Some useful insights

Here are some of his claims that I have also made in various posts, and are to be found in various of my web page items.

The much discussed "loss of wages" in the US since the 1980's (or 70's or 60's or 50's depending on your source) is really a decrease in the rate of incrase. If the "overcorrection" that the CPI makes for inflation is considered, wages have continued to grow, just at an ever slower rate. See my "Inflation & Federal Reserve Policy" or "Are Things getting Better or Worse?" for examples.

Opponents of foreign trade talk about the "loss of jobs", while supporters stress the "gain in jobs". Economic theory claims neither: the number of jobs is not predicted to change because of foreign trade, but the kind of jobs will. Or to say it another way, both sides are correct. Many jobs will be lost and an equal number gained. See my "Use of Statistics".

While international trade does have the effect of reducing the gap between rich and poor worldwide, it also has the effect of widening that gap in the USA. The poor and unskilled here are put into competition with the poor and unskilled abroad: the rich and skilled here have a wider market for their skills and talents.

While international trade is a good thing, it is not really all that important to the US economy. Only about 10 % of our total economy is connected to trade. (But I think he understates the impact. Consider that about half of the oil we burn is imported, but it would cause some major readjustment of our economy if that were cut off- see "The Economics of CO2" on the Environment section of my web page.)

A claim he makes that I have not is this: he says that the critics of foreign trade have not gone "beyond" the basic economics text book explanations of comparative advantage. They haven't even understood the basics! They are referred as Pop Internationalists.

On being interesting

In his presentation of economic ideas, Krugman does sound a bit like he is telling us to eat more vegetables and get more exercise. Of course he is correct. As Bill Buckley said in response to a similar criticism, it is hard to come up with "interesting" and "novel" ideas and proposals if you confine yourself to eternal truth.

Essays on related topics...

Title Author
Did Monetary Forces Cause The Great Depression? Jim Blair
"The End of Work" Jim Blair
Fukuyama's "The End of History and the Last Man" Jim Blair
Negative Population Growth Jim Blair
America Doesn't Have 'Class' Jim Blair
Is Class A Useful Distinction? Jim Blair
A common-sense approach to capital gains taxes Jim Blair
"The Future Of Capitalism" Jim Blair
Leadership on the Gas Crisis: Repeal the Tax? Jim Blair
Income Inequality and Stratification: Same Thing? Jim Blair
Inflation and Monetary Theory Jim Blair
Does The Minimum Wage Increase Unemployment? Jim Blair
"Pop Internationalism" Jim Blair
Supply Side Economics Jim Blair
Trade And Economic Development Jim Blair
Trickle-down Economics and Ronald Reagan Jim Blair
Raise The Minimum Wage: But Not For The US! Jim Blair
A Review of Keynesian Economic Theory Steve Kangas [off site]
Are We Homo Economicus? Steve Kangas [off site]
Liberalism's Economic Record Steve Kangas [off site]
A List Of Government Success Stories And Free-Market Failures Steve Kangas [off site]
President Carter vs. Reaganomics Steve Kangas [off site]
Tax Cuts Don't Increase Tax Revenue Steve Kangas [off site]
Timelines of the Great Depression Steve Kangas [off site]
Unregulated Capitalism Exploits Workers Steve Kangas [off site]
Welfare Doesn't Increase Poverty Steve Kangas [off site]

Number of unique visits to Big Issue Ground so far...

visits so far...